Evil Lupin/McGonagall

[random_monkey0_0]

No: HPFGUIDX 39915

On Evil!Mcgonagall:
> > Mysteryreefer:
> > 
> > > OK, I read all the posts regarding Evil Minerva and I have 2 
> > > questions-- if she is indeed so powerful, why couldn't she 
> > > conjure up a patronus to ward off the dementor from Barty Jr.? 

Dogberry:
> It could be that it happened too fast for her to stop. She had to 
> stay with Crouch Jnr, if Fudge came in, she may not have seen the 
> dementor in time. Remember that Snape saw it as well. 
> Also, Lupin said that many grown wizards have trouble with the 
charm, 
> Mcgonagall said so herself, that she is not the best at charms in 
POA 
> when she said that she would take the Firebolt to Flitwick.

But Barty Jr. knew a *lot* of stuff. One of the main arguments of the 
Evil!Fudge crew is that Fudge purposely led the Dementor to Barty in 
order to save the heinies of a lot of DEs. If McGonagall were evil, 
she would have let the Dementor kiss Junior, then pretended to be 
shocked. 

On Evil!Lupin, David_Burnett:
> For sheer practicality, I'm not sure JKR turns someone that popular 
> bad. It's simply not good business. :)

Have you ever been to somelace like Fanfiction.net? Do a search or 
Severus Snape and see how many Mary Sues (or even Gary Stus) you find. 
(I don't know why I bring this up, since I am adamantly against 
LYCANTHROPEs. In fact, I think Evil!McGonagall is silly, too. I just 
don't like theories to be disproved with faulty evidence. That, and I 
like to argue. ;^_^)

The Random Monkey, who, for sme reason, seems to love arguing with 
David