Albania/DISHWASHER/SPYGAMES
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Wed Jun 19 17:54:53 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 40064
Why Albania?
I thought the choice of Albania as Voldemort's hiding place was
meant to reflect the real world situation at the time when Rowling
was planning her tale. Albania was politically isolated. There
was almost no trade or tourism with other countries.
I got the idea that though magical Albania has a ministry of
magic and is nominally a member of the International
Confederation of Wizards, it is controlled by the vampires and/or
other beings hostile to wizardry. Only a few wizards can get both
authorization from their own ministries to visit and permission
from the Albanian ministry of magic to enter. Bertha probably
called on her family and ministry connections (they do seem to
have wanted to get rid of her) while Quirrell gained admission as
a scholar.
As we know, non-human magical beings are not allowed the
use of wands, so maybe there aren't a lot of wands available in
Albania in the first place. (The fact that non-humans as powerful
as centaurs, goblins and vampires have agreed to the ban has
always suggested to me that wands must be a mixed blessing.)
It could be that visiting wizards aren't normally allowed to bring
their wands with them. That wouldn't have bothered Quirrell, who
is an expert on wandless magic as shown by the scenes at the
end of PS/SS, but it would explain why Bertha didn't have a wand
on her.
This makes Albania a good place for Voldemort to hide from the
Aurors, but not a good place to encounter a wandering wizard
who might be persuaded to use his wand for Voldemort's benefit
or to allow himself to be possessed. There is no canon that
Voldemort can take over an unwilling wizard (Ginny willingly
poured out her soul) and it seems unlikely. Otherwise Voldemort
could just take over Dumbledore or even Harry himself. Perhaps
Harry's first dream in Gryffindor tower, where he hears a voice
telling him to transfer to Slytherin, was a failed attempt to
possess him.
The SPYGAMES/DISHWASHER theories present the battle as a
contest of wits rather than good vs. evil, but so far we actually
have the characters, for all their intricate plotting, making dumber
mistakes than their surface reading counterparts. It would be
grossly foolish of Dumbledore to offer Pettigrew to Voldemort for
the MAGIC DISHWASHER unless Dumbledore knew that
Voldemort had no easy alternatives to using Pettigrew for the
spell. But as Voldemort himself says, the task is one that many
of his followers would give their right hands to perform.
It is just as foolish for SPYGAMES!Voldemort not to realize that,
having expended his one irreplaceable resource, his immortality,
for the sake of killing Harry, he has committed himself to a fight
to the finish. He gains nothing by letting Harry get away. Time is
now on Dumbledore's side not Voldemort's, because though
Dumbledore may be weakening with age, Harry is growing
stronger. And now Voldemort will be aging too.
Ultimately, SPYGAMES leaves us back where we started, with a
battle of good vs. evil. Voldemort plans to allow Harry to escape
the graveyard because he, Voldemort, is not willing to face death.
Harry is going to win, not because Dumbledore has been more
clever than Voldemort, but because unlike Voldemort, Harry and
his friends don't consider their personal survival the highest
cause.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive