book differences - Wormtail's name
nplyon
nplyon at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 24 16:11:19 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 40270
>
> Incidentally, were any Americans (as a nation) insulted that the
American publishers thought no one would buy it if it had the
word "Philosopher" on the cover, hence the change to Sorcerer's Stone?
]
Hi all,
I'm new to the group and happy to have found a place to have
intelligent, literary discussions about the Harry Potter series.
Forgive me if I repeat anything that's already been discussed. I'm
trying to read through as many message as possible but there are
thousands.
I wanted to say that I am an American who was insulted by the name
change in the books. I was not much of a fantasy novel type reader
but even I knew what the Philospher's Stone was. I firmly believe
that making the changes taints the book somewhat. I have all four in
American versions and would like to purchase British versions to look
at the differences. At any rate, I think the publishers were a bit
insulting by implying that American children wouldn't understand
that "Mummy" is the same thing as "Mommy." I love the British flavor
of the novels. I've enjoyed trying to find out what things like
treacle tarts are!
I'm currently rereading GOF and I too noticed that Crouch referred to
Pettigrew as Wormtail. That seemed strange to me as I was under the
impression that these were secret names that only Potter, Black,
Lupin, and Pettigrew knew. If the names were generally known,
wouldn't it have been obviously to Fred and George who the creators
of the Marauder's Map really were?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive