[HPforGrownups] scar = alarm bell?

Pen Robinson pen at pensnest.co.uk
Mon Mar 18 14:55:15 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 36667

Steven Vander Ark said:

>   My question refers to a possible difference between
>   the UK and US versions of GofF. In the scene very
>   near the end where Dumbledore is trying to convince
>   Fudge that V. is back, Fudge says "I"ve never heard
>   of a curse scar acting as an alarm bell before".
>   It has been raised, on the HPGalleries forum, that
>   the UK version omits the word "never", which changes
>   the whole meaning drastically.

>Can anyone shed some light on this? Is there a difference at this
>point in the books between the US and UK versions? My US edition
>does say "never."

Certainly in my Stephen Fry audio book, the 'never' is omitted, and it is
very irritating indeed, as the sentence becomes absurd without it.  Grr.

Pen







More information about the HPforGrownups archive