Crouch, Voldie and motivations
ingachristsuperstar
ingachristsuperstar at yahoo.com
Sat Oct 19 05:07:09 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 45551
OK, I'll start with the usual apology for bringing this up if its
been
discused before. Now that that's overwith:
Does anyone have any thoughts on why Crouch!Moody was
trying to help/force Harry to _win_ the Tri-Wizard Tournament as
opposed to just entering him and assuring he finished the maze
first?
The champion who came first in the 3rd Task wouldn't
necessarily have won the Tournament would they? If so, why
bother with the first 2 tasks? But then, if Fleur had no chance
why was she still competing? So, we must assume that after
the winner of the 3rd task got the Cup (and arguably was
transported via port-key to the front of the maze) they might have
had to hand it over to the real winner of the tournament based on
points.
Anyway, this is all preamble to the real question. Why did
Crouch!Moody care so much how Harry did on Tasks 1 and 2 if
all he needed to do was get to the cup first?
Possible theories:
1. He wanted Harry to enter the maze first and so have a better
chance of finishing first. (possible, but he made it so easy for
Harry in the maze -and finished off the competition - that it hardly
mattered)
2. He wanted Harry to not die or be disqualified in the other tasks
(this one seems likely, I guess, but there were precautions in
place and no one was going to get hurt badly)
3. Voldemort wanted to show his followers that he could defeat
Harry Potter and thought it would make a more effective
demonstration if Harry had just won the tournament and thus
proven himself as a powerful wizard
or going even deeper
4. Voldemort _really wanted_ Harry to be a powerful wizard when
he faced him, either to prove to himself that he could beat a
powerful!Harry when he couldn't beat a baby!Harry, or
alternatively, to make the spell with Harry's blood even more
powerful.
Crouch!Moody's help with the tasks (as well as his training in the
Imperious Curse) no doubt made Harry a much more powerful
and confident wizard. Was this intentional? They planned for
Harry to be dead right after the 3rd task of course, so maybe they
never planned for the consequences if he wasn't and weren't
afraid that they were creating a possible enemy. Voldemort was
clearly putting on a show for the DE's lending evidence to theory
# 3. But we also know how arrogant Voldie is, and it would
seem that theory # 4 might have some credibility.
So, was Crouch!Moody ordered to make it seem that Harry was
a skillful wizard, or was he ordered to actually make Harry one?
Thoughts?
-Ing
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive