Tonks and Luna

[Inge]

No: HPFGUIDX 76134

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "S Handel" <fc26det at a...> wrote:
> Ok all you OOP experts.  I have been pondering this all day.  
> Dumbledore told Harry at the end of the book that he had been 
> watching him much closer than he could imagine.  Now, I wonder, 
since 
> Tonks is a metamorphmagis, is it possible that she is Luna?  I do 
not 
> recall them ever being in the same room together at the MOM.  Tonks 
> has the type of personality to pull off Luna.  And Luna has been at 
> the school since Ginny has been so she could have been watching 
Harry 
> from afar.  Isn't it strange that when Harry needs closer watching 
> Luna becomes a major character?  Both girls are a little "out 
there".
> Just wondering how DD has been keeping such a close watch on Potter 
> and the true purpose for Tonks to be a metamorphmagis.
> Susan

I had the same idea back in post #69098 but in the same message I 
also pointed out that Tonks and Luna actually DO appear at the same 
time in the same scene (UK edition p 713-714).

Nevertheless I still think it would have been a great plot if Luna 
and Tonks were one and the same!

Inge