[HPforGrownups] Re: Pettigrew WAS: Harry/Voldemort showdown in 2 years

[House Yolande]

No: HPFGUIDX 77872

Arya said:
> SNIP
> I think this is a possibility because I see Peter as being made to go with Voldemort, at least to the house at Godric's Hollow to show him the location  and break the charm (yes, I know he could have written it down, but I think Volde would make him come along).  Peter then could have witnessed  everything and after it was all done, have retreived the wand (maybe he even has other wands-- Lily's and James'???)

> Also, it is evident that Voldemort has his wand back in GoF, after Peter returned to him and was with him.  I am pretty certain that Fallen Voldemort could not possess and wield a wand so someone had to have saved it from the wrecjkage at GH and then given it back to him by the beginning of GoF (when the wand is used to kill Frank Bryce).  There are only two options: Crouch and Wormtail (or anyone of several ESE:  Snape, etc).  As Crouch is dead and gone, I see Wormtail as the most likely candidate.  

Then Ravenclaw Bookworm said: 

> A good explanation for how Voldemort got his wand back, too.

> This could also tie into the theory that Frank Longbottom witnessed the attack on the Potters.  (Cross reference: thread starting with #77595 / Witness to LV attack on Harry at Godric's Hollow).  If both Pettigrew and Frank Longbottom witnessed the attack, that would explain why the Death Eaters thought the Longbottoms knew where Voldemort was - Pettigrew would have told them he saw Frank there.  
Possibly Pettigrew hid so that Frank didn't see him, but he saw Frank.

And Yolande responds:
 
But if Pettigrew used Voldemort's wand, then wouldn't the Muggle victims of that attack have emerged from the wand at the end of The Goblet of Fire along with Harry's parents, Cedric, et al? Everyone who had died through the use of that wand emerged from it, starting with the most recent deaths. The scene with Sirius and Pettigrew happened after Harry's parents died; therefore, the Muggle victims would have come out of the wand before them, if in fact the wand had been used. Since they did not, it seems to me that this is solid proof that Pettigrew did not use Voldemort's wand. What do you think?
 
Yolande





---------------------------------
Lèche-vitrine ou lèche-écran ? Yahoo! Magasinage.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]