How can they tell who's a Muggle?

crunchy_chocolate_frog2003 <Crunchy_Chocolate_Frog@hotmail.com> Crunchy_Chocolate_Frog at hotmail.com
Tue Feb 18 09:49:15 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 52422

Greicy:

<<As I'm re-reading GoF, I've come to a halt.  How can Wizards, 
particularly the DEs, tell who is a Muggle?  It can't be because they 
wear Muggle clothing because the Weasley kids wear Muggle clothes.  
The only thing that can give a Muggle away is if they speak to 
someone and show them their lack of knowledge about the WW.  Unless 
you're Hermione.  :-D

So does anyone know the answer?  Has this been talked about before?>>


My opinion:

I think that wizards have some sort of sixth sense that they can tell 
if someone is a Muggle or a wizard.

I think that this sixth sense can also be witnessed in the Shrieking 
Shack scene, when Lupin returns the wands to the kids. It is probable 
that he is familiar with what their wands look like, having seen the 
kids use them all year long, but it's also possible that he sensed 
which wand belongs to which kid.

~~~~~~~~


Torsten:

<<Also, for all we know you need to be able to see an object you're 
casting a charm on.>>


My opinion: 

We know that seeing the object on which a spell is cast isn't 
necessary. In GoF, in the first task, Harry accio's his Firebolt 
without seeing the thing. But if the person *isn't* looking at the 
object which he is casting a spell on, then he should have a vivid 
image of it in his mind, he should be focusing on that thing, be 
familiar with what it looks like, where it is exactly, etc.

Crunchy Chocolate Frog (with a card of Wendelin the Weird)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive