OOP Re: Swan / Narcissa / Dementor / Fidelius Charm

[Michelle Bailey]

No: HPFGUIDX 67320

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Catlady (Rita Prince Winston)" 
<catlady at w...> wrote:
> I think OoP demonstrated that Dementors are Beings rather than 
Beasts 
> -- in the very first chapter, "Dudley Demented", when a Dementor 
> approaches Harry so closely that he can smell its foul breath, 
> "a voice spoke inside his head: 'Bow to death, Harry ... it might 
> even be painless ...  I would not know ... I have never died ...' 
> That is, the Dementor uses language, which is a major part of 
> distinguishing Beings from Beasts.
> 

I don't believe that this is the Dementor speaking. I believe this is 
Harry recalling the graveyard scene from GOF as the wording is 
exactly the same as what Voldemort said to Harry whilst he was 
duelling with him.
In POA Harry heard his parents dying, as this was his worst memory 
however now after the events in the graveyard - I believe that this 
is his worst memory and so he hears Voldemort taunting him when the 
Dementors get too close now.


Michelle