Harry and Death

spedlegs4169 rjpuntoni at attbi.com
Sat Jul 5 01:17:39 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 67490

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "geophage" <geophage at y...> 
wrote:
> RJ wrote... "So does it take time after the death for these to be 
> visible to people? "
> 
> This does seem the most likely scenario... however my question is 
> this.  No matter how young, did not wee little HP wittness the 
death 
> of his parents, or does it not count if you are not old enough to 
> have remembered it?  To those that would say his parents died in 
> another room or outside fighting LV, I say no.  It is NOT movie 
> corruption, from the first time I read the books, I pictured Lilly 
> dieing with Harry in her arms.  Later we learn she is casting a 
> spell on him at this time to protect him, even further evidence he 
> was probably in view.


It must take some time or otherwise JKR made a mistake because Harry 
does not seem to notice them on his way back to the Hogwarts express 
after he witnesses Cedric's death. 
                 - Ray Ray






More information about the HPforGrownups archive