Metaphors

David dfrankiswork at netscape.net
Mon Jul 7 00:36:58 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 67906

Morgan D. asks:
> 
> Since the explanation is that Sirius died because he fell through 
a 
> metaphor, does that mean that if instead of a veil the Death 
Chamber 
> contained a bucket, and Sirius had accidentally kicked said bucket 
> and immediately dropped dead, that would have been acceptable in 
> terms of a good plot resolution?
> 
> Just a question.

Ah...  I hadn't seen the possibility that Sirius' death is really 
there for *comic* effect.  Yes, a true slapstick moment there.

Now, every time I read that passage, images of farms being bought, 
chips being cashed in, great kennels in the sky, and so on, will 
fill my mind.

Just an answer.

David





More information about the HPforGrownups archive