notreallynew!Snape Theory: KING OF SPAIN

[sjlupin]

No: HPFGUIDX 70911

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "sophineclaire" 
<metal_tiara at h...> wrote:
> After reading OotP, I still like to think that Florence and Severus 
> were the ones necking behind the greenhouse. Though given James' 
> habit of hexing anyone he felt like, could he be the one leading 
the 
> poor aspiring Herbology student down the road to the family way ;-)
>
<snip> 
Somewhere, something happened and she was killed 
> accidently on prpose by Voldemorts crew to either keep Severus 
inline 
> or keep Severus from walking towards the light.
> 


Hmmm ... I like this theory. I have always leaned towards the Snape!
Florence theory regarding this intsance. I don't have GoF with me, 
but I recall that when Bertha's image says 'I only caught him kissing 
Florence behind the greehouse' Dumbledore says sadly something 
like 'but why were you following him'. Perhaps Severus and Florence's 
relationship was secret and Bertha 'outing' them somehow led to the 
events you elude to - Bertha being killed by the DEs. There is 
somthing significant about this event and Dumbledore regrets that she 
was snooping on that day.


sjlupin