[HPforGrownups] Barty Crouch, Jr?

[Carolin Mönkemeyer]

No: HPFGUIDX 71391

> >I just had a thought last night while taking a walk and thinking
> >about HP (yah, pathetic, I know). When V talks about his faithful
> >servant at Hogwarts in GoF he is obviously talking about Crouch, Jr.
> >He (Voldy) seems to put alot of emphasis on the fact that he is his
> >only truly faithful servant, etc. After the dementors kiss, where did
> >Crouch go? He is still alive after all; it is mentioned more than
> >once that the kiss is a fate worse then death and that you are alive
> >but have no soul. Are we sure that Crouch, Jr. is completely out of
> >the picture? I mean Voldermort can resurrect himself from vapor,
> >could he somehow restore Crouchs' soul and get his most faithful
> >servant back?
> >
> >Just wondering what folks might think.
> >
> >sjlupin
>
> From Michael-
>
> I wondered this too. Actually, I wonder if the Dementor actually kissed
> Crouch. After all we never see it, but only hear about it. It could be
that
> some of the Dementors were on LV side already, so they could have just
> pretended. Also, it might be possible for the Dementors to restore the
soul
> by re-kissing the victim.
>
> About the faithful servent stuff. When Voldemort said that he seems to be
> refering to the Death Eaters that weren't in Azakaban. The ones in
Azakaban
> were very loyal, but were imprisoned, so they couldn't do anything. But
once
> they escaped, why would Vol need his souless, faithful servent.
Still...what
> happened to him?

Me.
These are good theories. But now here's mine:
You become a Dementor when you've been kissed by one. It could also be
possible that some kind of shadow of your soul is still inside you and that
this makes you longing for good feelings for this makes you desperate. It
could also be that this longing is so strong that you try to satisfy it by
getting somebody other's soul but it doesn't work and you try again and
again.... I mean that would explain thier powers.
This would mean that Crouch now is a dementor and therefore he could be more
dangerous....

Finchen