Snape Theories, Petunia's knowledge of the WW, Cho

[snapesmate]

No: HPFGUIDX 73354

> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, ash Leigh <ashtayne at y...> 
> wrote:
> > Ashleigh
> > I say this because he his an ex Death 
> Eater and should have known Sirius was innocent > >

>--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "bibphile" <bibphile at y...> 
wrote:
 > I disagree.  I don't think he knew Sirius wasn't a traitor.  The 
> only way he would know that Sirius wasn't guilty would be if he 
knew that Pettigrew was.  I don't think Voldemort told anyone who his 
spy near the Potters was. 
>If Snape had know that Pettigrew was on Voldremort's side I think 
> have would have told Dumbledore.
> 
> Snape came to Dumbledore and offered to turn spy.  Dumbledore did 
> not approach him.  
> bibphile

I think Moldywart kept his spies' whereabouts to himself.  I cannot 
fathom his trusting anyone for any reason.  I am drawing a blank 
about "Snape's conversion".  When was it revealed he went to 
Dumbledore, etc.  (maybe I need a "HP4memoryloss", LOL!) It has not 
only bothered me that he chose to stop Harry's occlumency lessons out 
of anger, but also that Harry never tried to remedy this even if it 
meant having someone else tell Dumbledore.  Of course, this had to 
happen so Harry was still suseptable to Moldywart's mind invasion.  
Harry's anger and stubborness are partially responsible for Sirius 
getting killed.  
Now, as for Petunia...  I was shocked at the things she seemed to 
know about the WW.  For instnce, she knew all about dementors and 
that they guard Azkaban.  I have to wonder just what else she knows 
about.
While I am at it, I think I'll have a go at Cho Chang as well...  I 
understand that they are young teenagers, BUT, why would she feel it 
is OK for her to yammer on about Cedric and his death, but get so 
jealous whenever Harry mentions Hermione who is his friend and never 
has been his girlfriend)?  The whole thing with Cho was a bit 
aggrivating and kind of silly with all the "problems" they had.  Was 
the whole part about Cho just to give Harry a memory (their kiss) to 
be so protective of when having Occlumency lessons?
Lynnette, who's mind is coming up with way too many questions today!