[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape Theories

[ash Leigh]

No: HPFGUIDX 73420

 --- Melanie Black <princessmelabela at yahoo.com> wrote:
> But as much as I hate Snape (and I'm sorry to all
> the Snape fans: but the man is an arrogant racist) I
> doubt he is a death eater.  For the main reason that
> she wouldn't say that if he was...she does not come
> right out and say clear things like that.  

My answer:
I said the same thing as you said above and more in my
first post on the Snape theories Melaine, that answer
up there was in reply to some of the people who
replied back to my own theories on Snape. :)

 ashleigh