A question about Mundugus?

portrait_of_mrs_black atalante at poczta.onet.pl
Tue Jul 29 19:13:11 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 73943

Melanie wrote:
> > Okay in the scene where he(Mundugus) woke up at dinner, 
apparently 
> after falling asleep at the meeting.  He says "I agree with 
Sirius,"  
> Is anyone curious what it is he was agreeing about?

And Elle wrote:
> Perhaps that Harry should be informed about Voldemort's plans.  It 
> seems like Sirius felt strongly about that issue.  Or else 
Mundungus 
> was just trying to cover up the fact that he was sleeping during a 
> high level meeting; 

well, it can be either of it, though ... it was a *big* meeting they 
had that night. Was it because of Harry's arrival in GP or was it 
just a coincidence and the meeting had been planned earlier? If the 
meeting was important because of Harry's arrival (if it was then I 
think that Mundungus really agreed about something with Sirius) - 
what was it (the meeting) about? Would the *keeping Harry informed* 
issue be something discussed at a meeting of the Order? I don't think 
so because if it was discussed then there would be no argument 
between Mrs. Weasley and Sirius that night. They would have to act as 
it was settled during the meeting. And they *did* have an argument. 
So what could be the matter discussed in a *big* meeting, during 
which Sirius would be one of the "sides" (so that some people would 
agree with him and some won't)? 

Any thoughts? 

"Cheers," screeched the
Portrait_of_Mrs_Black 
whose patronus usually takes the form of a whisky bottle;)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive