OOP: Harry's Patronus

kellymcj2000 kellymcj2000 at yahoo.com
Tue Jun 24 23:55:13 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 63324

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "flutterbyhex" 
<flutterbyhex at y...> wrote:
> 
> 
> Hi, really sorry if this question has come up before, I tried doing 
a 
> search and I keep getting blown off the site. Give me detention 
with 
> Umbridge or as someone on this site called her "Scumbridge".
> 
> I'm confused about Harry's Patronus, didn't he produce his Patronus 
> during a Quidditch match in front of the entire school when he 
> thought Malfoy was a Dementor. Why is it that no one remembers it? 
> Lupin saw it and congratulated Harry. Why is it such a shock to 
> everyone then?
> 
> Linda - Dazed and confused after hours reading these posts

Well, this may a little lame but...
Maybe a lot of people did notice, but most people, especially Ron, 
Hermione, and the others who cared about him, were only watching him 
to make sure he didn't fall off and he was just about to catch the 
snitch.  Of course Lupin would notice as he was teaching Harry about 
it.  Also, we do hear about how it's a lot easier to produce a 
patronus without real dementors around.  Maybe they're just surprised 
he could do it with the real thing attacking him?  I don't know.  
It's probably just an oops on JKR's part.  

"kellymcj2000" 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive