Didn't Harry see his mum die? & Thestral Theories...

silencescreamsatme silencescreamsatme at yahoo.com
Thu Jun 26 07:22:42 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 64149

Vicky:

> Unless A) he didn't actually see her die~ was asleep and I'm just
> remembering the cinematic approach to the scene or B) (and my niece 
thinks
> I'm nuts) his mother did not actually die!!!   OOOOH!  Now there's a
> question!  Did they ever actually find Lily's body or did they just 
assume
> she dissintegrated?  Is there a grave somewhere?  

Me:

I don't know if there is a grave somewhere, but the bodies WERE 
found. Sirius mentions seeing them in PoA, when he went to the house 
to check and see if they were all right, he found the house 
destroyed, Lily and James' bodies and little baby Harry all by 
himself...

The answer that I came up with is that it might have to be a death 
you REMEMBER seeing, and since Harry was just a baby, he doesn't 
actually remember seeing his mother die.

~Silence





More information about the HPforGrownups archive