OOP: It CANT be Nevilles Prophecy / Can Harry Die?

[J]

No: HPFGUIDX 64781

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "stardreams04" <
queenofthecampus at h...> wrote:
> <snip>
> We know from her prediction at the end of PoA that Trelawney cannot 
> remember what she prophesies, but I wonder if this information could 
> be forced out of her using Veritaserum or the Cruciatus curse, which 
> has been used more than once to extract information from people, even 
> breaking through powerful memory charms (i.e. Bertha Jorkins).\
> <snip>
> 
> Oooh, I'd be willing to bet you're right on that account. Maybe  
> Veritaserum would be ineffective, but I'd strongly suspect Cruciatus 
> would "jog" Trelawney's memory, so to speak. Of course, I think that 
> Dumbledore's insistence that Sibyll remain at Hogwarts was borne 
> partially out of kindness - who else would take in a Seer who only 
> had made two real predictions? But certainly the fear that Voldemort 
> might kidnap her would explain JKR's use of the word "sharply" to 
> describe Dumbledore's command that Trelawney stay.

Another reason that Dumbledore wanted Trewlaney to stay, and likely in line 
with his motivation to hire her in the first place, is to have ACCESS to the Seer 
who has had one and now two prophecies concerning Voldemort.  He would 
want her to remain around so he could have access to the knowledge of 
future prophecies.  

I now find it odd that Dumbledore never asked for a penmseive thought thread 
of her second prediction so he could accurately and completely hear it.  I also 
wonder if there was some automautic record of that one made and located in 
the DoM.  (It would be accessible by only Wormtail and Voldemort)

Side note:  I believe that the dull, non-glowing orbs indicate that the prophecy 
had already come to pass.  

Arya