OOP: Re: Hermione and also Snape

[melclaros]

No: HPFGUIDX 65045

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Trina" <triner918 at a...> wrote:
> Obligatory spoiler space:
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> I thought about it a bit.  Yes, it got that Odious Umbridge Woman 
> (from here on out known as OUW) taken care of for the rest of the 
> book, but Hermione *knew* that the Centaurs were less than pleased 
> with the humans and threatened any to come into the forest.  After 
> all, Harry and Hermione got out without harm earler because they 
> were "foals" and only left safely then because of Grawp.  Hermione 
> didn't exactly think that one through and did *willfully and 
> knowingly* put OUW into severe danger.  I am curious to learn what 
> Dumbledore said to her later.  You know he had to have words with 
> young Ms. Granger about it.  It distressed me more than Harry's 
> Crucio on Bellatrix, after all, he had just lost Sirius...
> 
> 



now me:
So it's not just me? Those kids luring OUW out to meet a violent 
giant and an army of Centaurs did smack of "the prank" to someone 
else?
Except if we choose to believe what we think we're supposed to 
believe the prank was just that--a prank, as in joke.(personally I 
DON'T believe that but that's neither here nor there). This, however 
can be construed as nothing less than premeditated attempted murder.
Hermione creeps me out. Sorry--if there ever was a Jr. Death Eater in 
the making, it's her.


Melpomene