Dumbledore, Organ Grinder (Fair is foul and foul is fair.)

Berit Jakobsen belijako at online.no
Thu Nov 20 15:34:52 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 85543

Clef wrote:

> DD is so good, he seems too good to be true, which means he 
probably is. WS isn't kidding when he said fair is foul and foul is 
fair. He also calls Riddle, "Lord Voldemort" (CoS Am. vers. pg.329 
and on), and as Harry pointed out to Snape in book 5 only DE's call 
him "Lord Voldemort." Or maybe book 2 was a slip up, b/c I can't find 
DD saying it again in any subsequant books. But then, if DD is above 
Riddle, he wouldn't call him his Lord, would he?

Me:

Just a little clarification: The DE's call their master "the Dark 
Lord", not "Lord Voldemort". they respect him/are too afraid of him 
to call him by his real name. Bellatrix went berserk when Harry dared 
to say his name in MoM... Only Dumbledore and Harry calls him "(Lord) 
Voldemort" (in OoP others like Hermione start doing it as well). So, 
DD saying "Lord Voldemort" is not really an argument for 
him "sympathizing" with Voldemort... Why is he using the 
title "Lord"? I don't know; maybe he's just being polite :-) He 
always insists on Harry addressing Snape as "Professor"... 

Berit





More information about the HPforGrownups archive