Perseus Evans

[scoutmom21113]

No: HPFGUIDX 95582

Megs wrote:
> I just reread the scene in OotP and I think there is a good 
possibility that Lilly 
> and Snape had a history prior to the scene. She reacts rather 
cooly to the slur 
> he spews at her, almost like she expects it. Maybe I am reading to 
much into 
> this but I like this theory. What if Lilly and snape are brother 
and sister with a 
> muggle mother and pureblood father? The father ashamed of his 
mixed 
> children (or possibly his family) he cannot recognize the mother 
of his 
> children. He takes his son, Perseus, who looks like him, and 
changes his 
> name to Snape, leaves his daughter, Lily, who favors her mother, 
and Snape 
> appears to be a pureblood, Lily is passed off as never having a 
magic parent 
> etc. However, Lily and Snape still know about eachother. 
Interesting thought 
> to pick apart.

Bookworm:
Okay, here's the first shot or two. What about Petunia? Also, 
Petunia says (in the hut on the rock) Our *parents* were so proud of 
her.

I do agree that there is a background between them; they've been at 
school together for five years by this scene. Think Hermione and 
Draco. Hermione wouldn't have taken that comment as calmly as Lily 
did, but then, she wouldn't be - -  I almost said she wouldn't have 
intervened if Harry did the same thing to Draco, but maybe she would 
have. I can't see Harry necessarily doing something to Draco just 
because Ron was board, but if he reacted to Draco in a similar way, 
Hermione probably would have intervened as calmly as Lily did. What 
would Harry have done to Draco at the end of OoP if Snape hadn't 
shown up when he did?

Ravenclaw Bookworm