Where did Snape go Was: Trelawney and Ignorance

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Mon Apr 19 13:14:50 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 96379

snipping prior posts<<
> 
> AmanitaMuscaria  
>>snip<<
> On this theme, does anyone else remember another time when someone 
> was supposedly looking for Harry and couldn't find him? The only 
one 
> I could think of is when Harry & Hermione take Umbridge into the 
> Forest - I always presumed that when Snape said he looked for them, 
> he didn't look very hard, but what if he did, but couldn't find 
them 
> for some reason, like, say, he hadn't got his wand on him? What I'm 
> saying is, I think DD and SS keep VERY close tabs on where Harry 
is - 
> whether they do anything about it is another matter, or whether DD 
is 
> otherwise occupied and then SS can vent some anger on Harry ...


Potioncat:
As I was finishing OoP, it seemed to me to be a long time between the 
DA leaving the forest and the Order members arriving at the DoM.  It 
seems Snape verified Serius was safe and thought(?) Harry was with 
Umbridge. Somehow (?) he learned they had gone into the forest and  
had not come out.  Did he look, then notify the order?  When did he 
stop looking and why didn't he find Umbridge?  Or did he find her and 
not care, since Harry wasn't with her. I believe it said he organized 
a search.  I wonder who else was looking?

And another missing moment.  Back in CoS, Quirrell says that Snape 
watched him closely.  So why didn't Snape know that Quirrell was in 
the Chamber? or at least that both Quirrell and the trio were 
unaccounted for?

Potioncat once again raising more questions than answers





More information about the HPforGrownups archive