Was Harry Alone?

[fiondavhar]

No: HPFGUIDX 96600

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, danielle dassero <drdara at y...> 
wrote:
> Or what you saw in the trailer was shoddy editing,
> that shot used 2 or more cameras to film it and of
> course the cameras may have caught the other camera
> men and just didn't edit it out and because of the
> angle it just looks very faint. If JKR wanted us to
> see something by Harry when he produces the Patronus
> she would have said so in the book. Harry would have
> seen 2 people standing across the lake not one or when
> he realized he did he would have seen the other person
> faintly.
> Danielle
> 
Bonny now:

My point is that Harry was not supposed to see it in the books. A 
clue. Just because Harry doesn't see it doesn't mean it isn't there. 
As for shoddy editing, on a film of this magnitude such a huge 
mistake simply would not be made. The figure was obvious enough for 
more than one person to spot it, and editors wouldn't have missed it. 
That is, after all, their job. As for Harry seeing two figures across 
the lake, the figure was quite a ways behind him, so he wouldn't have 
ben able to see it (in the shade of the forest) from across the lake.

In any event, this is turning into a discussion about the trailer, 
and I am starting to feel really guilty about posting it in the first 
place, so maybe we should just drop it...

Bonny, looking sheepish because this is getting so far from canon.