How Close Are Harry and Lupin?

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 96779

Alla: 
 
> Well, I also don't buy ESE! Lupin (Sorry, Pippin!) But I also have 
to 
> admit that Lupin's deathgrip on Harry bothers me. The reason I find 
> this scene to be suspicious is that Lupin was waaay too calm for 
> someone who just lost his oldest friend.
> 
> Let's say that Sirius is not really dead. (Indulge me for a 
> second. :o)) Suppose Lupin was involved from the beginning in 
> planning of Sirius' dissappearance for some unknown reasons. Yeah 
> that's it. :) (I can dream, can I?)
> 
> If Sirius is really and sincerely dead though, then Lupin reaction 
> bothers me.
---------
Finwitch:

Might I present a theory:

Behind the Veil is the place where Members of the Werewolf Society 
transform. Lupin is a member so he knows the secret. Any normal human 
inside would, of course, be killed during Full Moon.

To protect the secret, only the Members can open the way out. Every 
member, how ever, is under a pact not to reveal that secret to anyone.

Lupin knows perfectly that he'll be able to protect Sirius 
(considering he's animagus and can hang around with werewolves - 
that's what they did since fifth year, after all).

Ok then, Lupin could get Sirius out. Why would HE, then, be worried?
(I think Lupin is going to keep Sirius there until Sirius is cleared 
of all charges, and only visit him from time to time, though).

--Finwitch