DD: an appreciation plus Lupin - again.

Meredith msmerymac at yahoo.com
Thu Apr 29 23:49:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 97320

> 
> Finwitch:
> 
> I'm going with the watch. After all, we DO know that Molly's clock 
> has that sort of ability. And yes, I think it has 3 hands for 
Potters 
> (so he knew Harry to be alive and Lily&James dead), 3 for 
Longbottoms 
> (Well, Neville was the *other* prophecy kid.) <snip> and another 
for whoever was Secret Keeper 
> for Neville Longbottoms whereabouts...
> 

Luckie:
This is something I hadn't thought about. (Forgive this post if PoA 
mentions it and I've just forgotten.) If the Potters had a Fidelius 
charm, why not the Longbottoms? Afterall, Harry and NEville were 
equal until Voldy marked Harry. And who was the Longbottom's secret-
keeper? And why were Frank and Alice found by crouch jr, R&R 
Lestrange, and Bella able to find them if they had a secret keeper? 
(I don't have GoF with me - were the Longbottoms tortured after 
Voldy's dissappearence? Was the Fidelius charm lifted at the time?)

~Luckie






More information about the HPforGrownups archive