The Veil, HP & LOTR

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 120859


> Silvana:
> How about Snape being the match for... Gollum! :-D JKR
> describes him as an ugly person. Once he was on LV's
> side (as an active DE) now he has changed sides and
> helps DD and Harry. He lives in the Dungeons as did
> Gollum. Ron (=Sam) hates him and doesn't trust him.
> Harry (= Frodo) has learned Snape's story from the
> Pensive (belongs to DD! = Gandalf) and he understood 
> Snape's reactions / felt ashamed for his father.


Alla:

Hmmm, I can see similarities, but I hope not. Sorry! Golum does not 
do the right thing at the end (although it helps anyway) and I hope 
Snape will just as Boromir did (maybe he will even be lucky to 
survive).

Besides, Boromir also fell to darkness for very short time, so here 
is similarity to Snape.



Best,

Alla