[HPforGrownups] Marietta and Hermione (was JKR's Messages ) (was Re: Hermione In Trouble?)

[charme]

No: HPFGUIDX 120861

<snipping all the other Eggplant/Del exchange & adding one at the bottom of 
this post>

> Eggplant wrote:
> "What about the time when he was 14 and magically arm wrestled with
> Voldemort and won?"
>
> Del replies:
> Is there any other witness to this than Harry?
>
> Do you really expect everyone to believe the word of a single teenage boy?

charme now,

Actually in GoF's arm wrestling between LV and Harry, there are witnesses: a 
bunch of Death Eaters. There's also the supporting confession of the plan 
from Barty Crouch, Jr made to DD and others after the TriWizard competition. 
While everyone might not believe the word of a single teenage boy, others 
did. Isn't that canon?

> Del replies:
<snip>
>is "what I like is right and good and
> what I don't like is evil and wrong", which prompts me to ask : are
> you a god?

charme again,

This is just my 2 cents and may be off topic (List Elves, I'm SORRY!!!) as I 
have seen this question posed before in debates on this message board 
several times and I'd submit what a friend of mine tells me:  everyone is a 
"god" in their own heads, so as he says, asking the question is pointless. 
:)