Sirius and Percy... also HBP (was: Re: Dumbledore and Sirius; Percy Weasly; Defending Percy; Slytherin as HBP)

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 105275

Amey:
> And as for penseive, if it shows "a memory of that person's version 
> of what happened.", it's pretty subjective, and the scene might 
> even be different. 

SSSusan:
May I ask whom you're quoting here?  Could you clarify for me, 
please?  

I don't recall ANY word from JKR on the nature of the Pensieve.  And 
personally, I'm with Ces in the belief that the Pensieve is an 
objective thing; otherwise, could Harry have "moved around in" 
Snape's memory so much and seen & heard things [such as the chatter 
amongst the Marauders] that Snape didn't?

Siriusly Snapey Susan