[HPforGrownups] Digest Number 4890

[Amey Chinchorkar]

No: HPFGUIDX 105459

>> From: "gelite67" <gelite67 at yahoo.com>
>> Subject: Harry's Pensieve
>> Could Dumbledore would give Harry his own pensieve and extract 
>> Harry's latent memories from his first year?


Amey:
>From what we have see, I think only memories the person rememebers can be taken out of head (I presume). 

>> Angie
>> I don't see how Lucius would have gotten the diary from 
>> Tom and I can't see why Lucius would be motivated to help Tom as 
>> opposed to Voldemort.
>> leb2323
>> "Does this mean that TR and LM were at school together?  Why 
>> does Lucius have them and what else can we expect to see?"

Amey:
Both can't be in school together, as the last opening of the CoS was before Luciou's time as Draco tells Harry and Ron after they have drunk Polyjuice Potion. And as for being motivated to help Tom as opposed to LV, they are both one and the same.

"Voldemort," said Riddle softly, "is my past, present, and future, Harry
Potter . . . ." (CoS)

OOps, have I just put an end to the debate that LV and TR are different or something??


>>Leb:
> I know and will readily admit right off the bat that this is 
> farfetched, but how widespread is the 'help will be given' part of 
> this advice.  When I read this part I immediately thought of the 
> scene in OOtP where Harry is desperately trying to remember 
> something 
> in one of his OWLs, silently asks for help, and ends up reading 
> either Lavender or Parvati's mind to get his answer.  

Amey:
He didn't read her mind, he wished he could. He concentrated hard and raked his brains.

>> Me, Aggie:
>> I agree, I think that the sword has only been in DD's office SINCE 
>> CoS.  I believe that it did not 'exist' before Harry pulled it out of 
>> the hat.  

Amey:
We have only seen Dumbledore's office once before that, and then Harry was more interested in The Hat and Fawkes than seeing around. So the point is fully open.

>> vmonte wrote:
>> <snip>
> Ron is also going to have new memories to explore in the next book.
> The brain has to be someone important to be kept at the DoM. 

Amey:
Gryffindor's brain anyone? Connection to HBP? I mean I have read many posters thinking Ron is HBP, he may have the memories of HBP (Gryffindor maybe, Slytherin... horrible thinking) rather than being one.

Amey, who has started thinking of possiblities of The Brain and Ron 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]