[HPforGrownups] Re: Sirius/Tonks

[Kathy King]

No: HPFGUIDX 93636


>Berit said>
>I don't quite see how it can be consistent with Sirius's personality
>to pass as Tonks and let Tonks pass as him in a potentially very
>dangerous undertaking; letting her play the high-risk part. I could
>see the point of doing it if Tonks (impersonating Sirius) stayed at
>Grimmauld place and Sirius masked as Tonks went to the MoM. But they
>both came along...
>
>Statistically Sirius is more likely to get injured or killed since
>he's already a fugitive and a wanted man. Can you really see
>him "hiding" as Tonks and letting her take the blows meant for him?

Kathy's thoughts:

I think you may have hit on the very reason they did change. If the ministry 
officials were to have captured Tonks as Sirius, all Tonks would have to 
have done is switch back. In fact, she could be very slippery to catch being 
able to inpersonate anyone at will. (Even Fudge himself)
As far as putting Tonks in danger, I never gave it a second thought seeing 
as she is an Auror and should no just as well as Sirius how to fight. I 
wouldn't think that Sirius would feel that he was endangering her in the 
least. In fact, if this did take place it was most likely Tonks who thought 
of it to protect Sirius.


Kathy-Still trying to keep Sirius alive!

_________________________________________________________________
Is your PC infected? Get a FREE online computer virus scan from McAfee 
Security. http://clinic.mcafee.com/clinic/ibuy/campaign.asp?cid=3963