Sirius/Tonks

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 93637

 >snip<
> Kathy wrote:
> >snip<
> I think you may have hit on the very reason they did change. If the 
ministry 
> officials were to have captured Tonks as Sirius, all Tonks would 
have to 
> have done is switch back. In fact, she could be very slippery to 
catch being 
> able to inpersonate anyone at will. (Even Fudge himself)
 >snip<
> Kathy-Still trying to keep Sirius alive. 
(Keeping signature line on purpose)


Potioncat here:
Kathy, as a fellow Kathy and a fellow grasper of straws I applaud 
your theory.  But I do disagree.  If Tonks/Sirius changed back into 
Tonks, she'd go to Azkaban for aiding a known criminal.  Sirius 
hasn't been cleared by the official government.  

Also, if JKR did write it this way, most of us would have grieved for 
Sirius (readers and characters alike) and then would have to grieve 
for Tonks in the next book.
Potioncat 
> _________________________________________________________________
> Is your PC infected? Get a FREE online computer virus scan from 
McAfee® 
> Security. http://clinic.mcafee.com/clinic/ibuy/campaign.asp?cid=3963