Seeing Sirius Again (was: Re: Sirius/Tonks)

rorogersmc rorogersmc at yahoo.com
Tue Mar 23 04:28:13 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 93722

Snip of Kathy's post:
>>In the most resent interview with Jkr, someone had asked if Sirius came 
back what *form would he be in? Jkr said she couldn't possibly answer that 
question for fear of incriminating herself. Incriminate: to provide 
evidence of somebody's guilt or make somebody appear guilty of a crime or 
mistake.

What is she guilty of?


Kathy(snow15145) -who hopes she is guilty of killing Tonks instead of 
Sirius.<<



Rachael Replies:
Sorry, but I agree with others who have stated that Sirius IS dead.  Don't we wish he 
could come back, but I highly doubt he will be back in any living form, or as a ghost.  
Nearly Headless Nick sadly tries to tell Harry that wizards don't come back when 
they've passed on.  However, the answer JKR gives to the question of *what form 
would Sirius be in if he comes back* does make it sound like he will show up again.  I 
would be interested in any ideas about how else Sirius might show up again 
(excluding really being alive, or a ghost). 
 Here's a possibility I've thought of.  Bellatrix cast the spell that killed Sirius, so if 
Priori Incantatem happened to her wand, it is possible that a form of Sirius would 
come out, just like Harry's parents in GOF.  I wonder if there are other ways to initiate 
Priori Incantatem besides brother wands fighting against each other, and if so, will it 
occur in books 6 or 7.

What do you think?  A future shadow/echo of Sirius happening?  Or maybe, if Harry 
obtains Bellatrix's wand he could initiate Priori Incantatem when ever he wanted to 
see Sirius.

Rachael, whose finally glad to post this idea which has been floating in her head for a 
while.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive