[HPforGrownups] Hagrid's blunder or can any student by head boy/girl

[MadameSSnape at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 94003

In a message dated 3/25/2004 10:10:36 PM Eastern Standard Time, 
witchwriter_no1 at yahoo.com writes:

    Anycase, coming to Lilly being prefect and head girl( most 
possibly both) , we have no canon evidence that they were both from 
the same year. The students of one year write the exams together in 
one hall. If Lilly had been in the same year, then she would have 
written the exam in the big hall(to which Harry had been transposed 
through Snapes pensieve.). But she was not to be discussed in the 
hall I therefore strongly feel she must have been a year or more 
younger than the Marauderers and Snape. She was among other girls 
under a tree when the marauderers came out of the exam hall. 

===================================

Sherrie here:

Harry was concentrating on his father, and finding the other Marauders - he 
didn't think to look for his mother, she never even crossed his mind til she 
(forcefully!) entered the picture.  However, Harry is, IIRC, described as 
exiting the hall WITH the group of girls in which Lily is included - which would 
mean that yes, she WAS in the OWL hall.

Just my two Knuts - as ever, YMMV.
Sherrie
"Unless history lives in our present, it has no future." 
PRESERVE OUR CIVIL WAR BATTLEFIELDS!


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]