[HPforGrownups] Re: Dark? Sirius

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 114796

     Dumbledore also said that Sirius' actions were not those of an 
innocent man.
 
     Sirius was the one who talked James into making Pettigrew his 
secret keeper.

     I don't think that Pettigrew had the guts to successfully be a spy 
for a year before Voldemort fell

     In GoF Voldemort tells his deatheaters that his servant is at 
Hogwarts.  At that time, there is Sirius, "sitting in the pumpkin 
patch".  There are always two.

     Sirius' brother was killed for joining and then backing out.  
Sirius was never bothered, even as a friend of James Potter.

KJ

Sherry now

On reading what JKR says about Sirius on her web site, I don't see how she
can end up making Sirius the traitor.  Even while listing his faults,
reckless and all that, she says that his strongest positive trait is his
loyalty, loyalty to James and then to Harry.  If that is how she describes
him, as being loyal to James and then to Harry, I hope she won't turn around
and make it end up that he was the traitor and spy.  What kind of loyalty to
James would that be?

Sherry G