The Wizarding World: Expulsion & Hogwarts School

[sandra87b]

No: HPFGUIDX 127732


Steve <bboyminn at y...> wrote:
> I'm not 100% entrenched in my idea, I'm only saying the 
> regardless ofhow Hagrid says it, being banned for having 
> and using a wand is effectively the same as being banned 
> from performing magic.


Let's face it, the books are riddled with inconsistencies and loop 
holes, and very few people pick them up - especially the general 
public who still seem to worship every word. The book buying 
world (and film going world) are very forgiving to JKR. I'm not, 
and still dislike where JKR went with a childrens' book in TOoTP 
when Harry had to write lines which were carved into his hand. 
That was just plain sick, and messed up one of my friends' 
daughters for weeks.

Sandra (getting indignant)