It's over, Snape is evil (was: Dumbledore and Snape again)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138546

"colebiancardi" <muellem at b...> wrote:

> Snape only knows the first part of 
> the prophecy. Not the full part. 

Snape told Dumbledore he only heard the first half but I don't believe
him. I think Snape heard every word of the Prophecy but he only told
Voldemort half.  

> Much wiser people, like Arthur, Remus,
> Kingsley, can view that night in
> question & conclude what really happened 

They were not there, Harry was, and he already knows what happened.
And in the last book Harry proved to be much wiser than any of those
people, wiser even than Dumbledore. He kept telling them that Snape
was untrustworthy, he kept telling them that what Draco was doing in
the Room of Requirements was important and sinister and that Death
Eaters were going to get into the castle while Dumbledore and he were
away, but they just wouldn't listen. 

> up until the 3rd part of the UV,
> Snape thought he was getting off
> with just giving aid to Draco.
> When Cissa invokes the 3rd part,
> sealing Snape's fate, his hand 
> twitches. What could he do at that
> point? Yank it back and yell no? 

In a previous post I mentioned the tortuous contortions, gymnastics
and general back flips Snape lovers must go through to make their
theories fit the facts, the above is a good example of that. 

Eggplant