ACID POPS vs LOLLIPOPS (was:Re: Whom does Snape REALLY love?)
M.Clifford
Aisbelmon at hotmail.com
Sun Aug 28 09:34:08 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 138919
> > Neri:
> > > Do you remember Snape *ever* treating
> > > *anybody* else gently and kindly, in the whole series?
> >
> > Betsy Hp:
> > We've never seen him outside of Harry's presence before. Though
> > he *does* show a great deal of care, IMO, when he heals Draco from
> > the Sectumsempra. He struck me as downright maternal in that
> > scene.
>
> Neri:
> Snape had a *very* good personal motive to treat Draco carefully
> there. Had Draco died, or even merely came to some harm from the
> Sectumsempra, then Snape would be dead. In the bathroom scene Snape
> came within an inch of his death, and the only thing between them
> was Draco's well being.
>
> Except for the above well-explained case, Snape never shows even a
> hint of decent kindness towards Dumbledore, McGonagall, Filch or
> anybody *but* Narcissa. I don't see why Harry's presence should
> prevent him from that.
Valky surreptitiouly slips her Lollipop into her back pocket as she
approaches.
"AHA! I saw that!" Neri cries pointing at her.
Valky looking bashful:
I um... I only bought one yesterday, and I haven't even tasted it yet
I promise. This is not about that anyway, I just have to make that
clear, I just agree with Betsy, Snape was downright maternal.
I wouldn't use it to take the fizz out of the Acrid Pops though.. oops
I mean Acid pops.. I just can't stand Snape in love with anybody, it
doesn't work for me. *shivers*
I like Snape as a unicorn, the lady trapped him because he soft on
women, especially beautiful fragile princesses like Narcissa. His
gentleness with Draco's injury just smoked of protectiveness of the
child.
But back to the Sweets stalls I have a feeling that both will still
stand on at least a leg after the class seven rolls through TBAY.
Snapes sweetness on the princesses IMHO is about as close to love as
he is capable of apart from his avid concern for the saftey of
innocents. I just wonder what would happen here if I am right about
that. ;P
MHO is that if the Snape mystery ends with a simple he was a bit sweet
on them both, it won't really resolve the core of either of these
theories. I am quite sure that some of Snapes hatred toward Harry will
be proven to have roots in his angst for Harry's Mother, AND the UV
will be added up to a bit too much passion for the alluring lady in Mr
Snape. But neither will be the complete explanation. Maybe I am just
barking at the wrong Tbay market, and should open a stand of my own.
;D
GO! LOLLIPOPS and GO! ACID POPS...
Valky just essentially enjoying the tennis match. :D
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive