Snape and Prophecy and Harry WAS:Re: TBAY: Definitely NOT a Snape Theory (long)

[Corey Overton]

No: HPFGUIDX 145456

Alla:
> Oh, of course, how DARE Harry to blame the person who told 
> Voldemort that his parents are the parents of the one who 
> will dispose with Voldy eventually? <snip> How dare he think 
> that but for Snape's involvement he may have grown up in 
> happy home and not abusive one? 
>
> Of course Snape is NOT to blame for blabbing prophecy to 
> Voldemort, because Lily and James would have died in any 
> event. He is also NOT to blame for treating Harry like dirt 
> in the classroom, because Harry needs to be kept in line or
> because Harry can deal with it or because Snape is too damaged
> and cannot help himself. :-)
>
<snip>
>
> So, NO I don't buy "chose to leave him orphaned" at all. More 
> like "died protecting him" IMO and with this Harry deals and 
> deals very maturely.


Corey again here. I'm with Alla. I agree that a lot of people 
have died for Harry. As far as Snape, I just don't see how so 
many people can think he's DDM when they all know he killed him, 
jmo of course. But like they say there's 2 sides to every story. 
I once again agree with Alla when she says the thing about "Snape 
treating Harry bad in class." Well that's my opinion. Hope I 
combined this all right. 

Your fellow member, 
Corey