Marietta and Hermione (was JKR's Messages ) (was Re: Hermione In Trouble?)

[eggplant9998]

No: HPFGUIDX 120954


"delwynmarch" <delwynmarch at y...> wrote:

> Let's say you see Man A chasing Man B 
> with a bloody axe. If I understand you
> well, you will automatically classify 
> Man A as an evil monster, right? 

Wrong. In my example I was man B, and that changes things. 

> I know the difference between "I like 
> what's right" and "what I like is right".

I do too, one has the word "what's" in it and the other
has the word "what" in it. It's called logic, if I 
like what's right then what I like is right AND if what I like is 
right then I like what's right. Therefore, according to good old 
Aristotelian logic the two terms are equivalent, that is,
there is no test that can differentiate between them. 
ou are making a distinction without a difference.    

> So why "should" the general public 
> know about them [Death Eaters]? 

Because the two most important Wizards of the age, Harry and 
Dumbledore, told them about it, not to mention the entire faculty of 
Hogwarts, even Snape. And if people don't believe them then they
are WRONG.   

> Nobody else has reported seeing even the
> smallest bit of Reborn!LV 

Barty Crouch jr saw him and told what he saw, and we know for a fact 
he could not be lying. And if people don't believe him then they
are WRONG. Wrong is not good.

Eggplant