Umbridge and Hermione was Marrieta and ...

[TrekkieGrrrl]

No: HPFGUIDX 120979



Pippin:
> > asking Harry to call Fawkes

Eggplant:
> If Harry has the ability to call Fawkes to him whenever he wants
> that's news to me. By the way, how could she ask Harry
> anything without Umbridge hearing her do so?<

Pippin: (quoting from memory) "You must have shown true
> loyalty to me. Only that could have called Fawkes to you." --CoS
> Hermione could have said, "I hope our golden friend isn't there,
> he might cause trouble." Harry's quick on the uptake, he'd have
> figured it out.


I doubt Harry is able to consciously call Fawkes. When he summoned the 
Phoenix in CoS he didn't know he was doing it. He summoned him by believing 
in Dumbledore, but what he really summoned was Godrick Gryffindors sword, 
Fawkes was only the "carrier pidgeon" in that case, although of course it 
also helped later on with the healing tears and by helping them out of the 
chamber.

~TG