In Defense of Snape (long)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 122329



Alla:

Suppose that Snape was present at the exam. Harry KNOWS the answer, 
but Snape's presence could have stopped him from answering the 
question up to his true potential. He could not have used his 
ability to show understanding at all.


Shaun:
 
Why not?

I don't see any reason to think that Snape's presence at the 
examination would have affected Harry at all. We know Polyjuice 
potion was at least mentioned in class in second year, and 
presumably examination questions are based on what students have 
studied, so Harry would have no reason to conceal his knowledge.


Alla:

You misunderstood me. I did not mean that Harry will be afraid to 
write about Polyjuice potion. I meant that Snape's presence may be 
terrorising per se ( and fear MAY stop you from remembering the 
answer) or I will not put it behind him to sabotage Harry's grade on 
purpose , like... I don't know  throw the vial with potion on the 
floor.

JMO,

Alla