Favorite Snape Scenes - He's such a lovely professor, no really.

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 122783


Renee wrote:
Ah, but when has not knowing something stopped us from making
deductions? :)
By the time Snape finds Sirius, Harry and Hermione unconscious, the
situation has changed. Snape has a better opportunity to think now.
What will happen if he calls the Dementors (provided he could have
done so; I've got no idea where they went and I don't know how long
the effects of a Patronus lasts)? Will they only Kiss Sirius and
leave Harry and Hermione alone? They *have* shown an unhealthy
interest in Harry before. Can Snape prevent them from sucking out
the soul of the boy he's trying to protect? And even if he can
protect Harry, there are no witnesses if the Dementors Kiss Sirius
while the two students are out; how can he prove his own role?
Better take everyone to the castle. To me, this seems a likely
scenario.

vmonte responds:
Nice response Renee. I would bet that this is exactly what Snape was 
thinking.  Your reasoning, IMO, sounds very much like JKR's.   

Vivian :)