Snape Haters Club

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 133579

> fourfuries at a... wrote:
> >if you read the few excerpts available from the most recent 
> > interviews, it becomes patently obvious that Snape is evil.  
There 
> > is no way in the world for him to settle up with Harry.  In fact, 
> > JKR says that it is now as personal between them as it is between 
> > Harry and Lord Thingy, if not more so.
> 

Snipsnapsnur: 
<SNIP>
> But Harry doesn't know everything. And let me ask this: Does anyone 
> seriously believe that Dumbledore would have survived the potion he 
> drank? I think his chances of survival were exactly zero.

 

Alla:

Erm... I do believe that Dumbledore could have survived. I asked 
this question, but I will ask it again.
Does he strike to you in a scene with Draco as " dying man talking"? 
Not to me, he is making plans for Draco, which HE himself intends to 
implement. After he takes an antidote from dear Snape, IMO.
This is a BIG question. Why Dumbledore called for Snape to ask for 
antidote or to beg to be killed?

I tend to believe  the first reason, personally.

I am also among those who wishes Snape to be dead in book 7 and t he 
only reason I don't want him to be ESE would be to prove Dumbledore's 
right. It is too painful for me to think that he died with the last 
thought of being betrayed by the person whom he trusted so much.

But as JKR said yesterday - Dumbledore makes mistakes. 

JMO,
Alla.