Explaining the danger to Harry (LONG)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 130109

D:
<SNIP>
So ironic that you quote back the so-called "quotes' claim that 
other person as prove "see? don't think anybody is ignoring anything 
here",  because it exactly points out how deliberately he IGNORE the 
following passagse.
 
Here's some of the quotes that are 'missing', (paste from other post)
 
..."The important thing is that THE DARK LORD IS NOW AWARE THAT YOU
ARE GAINING ACCESS TO HIS THOUGHTS AND FEELINGS.  HE HAS ALSO DEDUCED
THAT THE PROCESS IS LIKELY TO WORK IN REVERSE; THAT IS TO SAY, HE HAS
REALIZED THAT HE MIGHT BE ABLE TO ACCESS YOUR THOUGHTS AND FEELINGS
N RETURN -"
 
"AND HE MIGHT TRY AND MAKE ME DO THINGS?" asked Harry....

Alla:

Let's finish this quote, shall we? ;)

"He might," said Snape, sounding cold and unconcerned. "Which brings 
us back to Occlumency" - OOP, p.333, paperback.

Nope, does not sound to me as stressing importance of the lessons at 
all. If Snape sounded unconcerned, why exactly should Harry be more 
concerned than him?


D:
<SNIP>
Also [people cheer on thow 'absolutely right' Harry for not
listening and distrusting Snape, which means such right decision and 
right attitude also led to the RIGHT decision that to believe the 
false vision, making the RIGHT decision in going to MoM that led to 
Sirius's death. Sorry Sirius, you're RIGHT to die, you deserve
to die, because every bad decision, oops not bad but RIGHT, bottom 
line is Harry is right in not practicing.

Alla:

Nope, Harry was not RIGHT not to trust Snape, but he was justified 
in not trusting Snape, IMO. Snape gave him no reasons to trust him 
during these five years.

Remember ? "Mr. Potter, our new celebrity"

Remember than at the end of the POA they tried to tell Snape the 
TRUTH about what happened. What did they get in response? Oh, yes. 
The children were confunded.


Remember when Harry begged Snape to tell him where Dumbledore is in 
GoF when Barty Sr. needed help?

Yes, I do think that Snape ghave Harry no reasons to trust him 
whatsoever.

And yes, I do remember PS/SS, but Snape sure made a considerable 
effort to make Harry forget about it. :-)

  


Just my opinion,

Alla.