Kreacher

[kempermentor]

No: HPFGUIDX 128994

> > Tonks:
> > Maybe DD takes Kreacher to Hogwarts. If he is under service there 
> > cleaning the kitchen or something he can't get out to tell any 
> > secrets. Course he could have his memory altered too. Or maybe 
> > Mad-Eye took *care* of things and we will see ol' Kreacher on the 
> > wall.
> > 
> > Tonks_op
> 
> bboyminn:
> 
> I've already commented several times that I think Dumbledore
> 'dispatched', to put it politely, Kreacher and his head is now 
hanging
> on the wall with his ancestors. Kreacher is just to volatile and
> unstable to keep around.
> 
...
I see
> Kreacher as a dangerous and deadly problem that must be delt with. I
> would love for Hermione to woo him with kindness, or Dumbledore to
> turn him with logic, but I just don't see that happening. 


Kemper now:
If Dumbledore is so free with killing, why wouldn't he just kill all 
the DE's that are in the 'public' like Lucius, Crabbe and Goyle Srs., 
et. al.? That would greatly decrease potential harm to the Order, and 
to the WW/RW public.  But he's not free with killing, he's a man of 
compassion.  He knows why Kreacher is the way he is.  It's is because 
of this compassion that Dumbledore cannot kill.  I do not believe 
that should some wizard come after a student with intent to kill that 
DD would kill that wizard.  He would perform some other magic other 
than AK to halt the wizard.  Again, Dumbledore is a man of compassion 
and not a man of vengence.

Kemper