Sorting Hat as Horcrux?

[M. Thitathan]

No: HPFGUIDX 143388

  mercurybluesmng  wrote:     "Would you please explain what makes you think that Memory!Tom is 
separate from SoulFragment!Tom? That seems to be the main point of 
your argument, that Tom put the memory of his sixteen-year-old self 
into the diary, then went off and killed his dad and figured out how 
to make Horcruxes and attached a soul fragment to the diary too. I 
don't see how the memory is separate from the soul fragment, which 
does imply that Tom had both killed his family and figured out how 
to make Horcruxes before he hit seventeen. (Which, in point of fact, 
was in December.)"

CH3ed:
  Well, I think of the diary as primarily a penseive which LV made when he was 16 (quite an achievement for that age)... and LV made the diary penseive into a horcrux later (the soul bit then enable the memory to think and react with the outside world so that the 16 yrs old memory of LV could possess Ginny and the rest of the things it did in CoS that a normal penseive memory can't do). So the memory and the soul aren't separate. They were just put in the diary at different times. This is my speculation, of course, not a confirmed fact.



		
---------------------------------
 Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click.  

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]