Dumbledore's-death-is-a-fake-theory

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 143627

> n_longbottom01 wrote:
> > Dumbledore implies that he can hide Draco by faking his death
> 
> Miles:
> This is your interpretation. Dumbledore says, that he could hide 
Draco, not
> more, not less. The implication of a faked death is a possible
> interpretation, but only one among several other.


Alla:

Well, I believe that Dumbledore says a little bit more than that. 
Remember those words in American edition, which did not make it to 
British one? Unless of course you believe that JKR did not write 
them and it was an editor mistake. :-)


"He cannot kill you if you are already dead. Come over to the right 
side, Draco, and we can hide you more completely than you can 
possibly imagine." - HBP, p.592.

To me the implication of faked death is present here.

Now, don't get me wrong, I do NOT believe in Dumbledore's faked 
death theory, but not because of presence or absence such clues in 
the text, because we could find clues to support any theory we came 
up with, IMO and dragon blood and some other stuff certainly can be 
interpreted as clues.

I do NOT believe that JKR lies to us in interviews, I just don't and 
she went over and over saying that Dumbledore is dead, dead, very 
very dead, that she believes that it is more fun when hero has to do 
his job alone and she specifically said in interview with Emmerson 
and Mellissa that mentor always dies. So to me she cannot be any 
clearer in proclaiming to the world that Dumbledore is dead.

But at the same time why can't we do some wishful thinking? You 
know, while I just said all that stuff about interviews, I used to 
believe that Sirius is coming back and deep down I still do ( you 
know - no body and all that suff), even after Harry inherited 
Kreacher, which cannot be clearer proof that Sirius is dead. Is it 
wishful thinking? Of course it is, but it is part of the fun, so if 
people believe that Dumbledore is coming back and come up with great 
clues to support this theory - why not?

JMO,

Alla.
Alla