Identifying Enemies/Twins

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 141000

> Hickengruendler:
> 
> It doesn't matter. Fred and George knew very well, that Dudley was 
on 
> a diet and would seize every opportunity to eat a candy, as Arthur 
> rightfully pointed out. Therefore whatever Dudley did, was 
calculated 
> by Fred and George.

Finwitch:

Well, as I said earlier, people on diet are not supposed to eat 
candy. As for F&G leaving, they didn't even know if Dudley would eat 
it... (And Vernon/Petunia wouldn't, I suppose).

And as for the unseen concequences (DEs at Hogwarts) - well, things 
like that happen, but only Seers can predict them. Every action, 
regardless of intention, can have both positive and negative 
consequences.

Anyway, it was entirely possible that Dudley's tongue would have 
shrunk by itself, or even that the spell wouldn't work at all...

I doubt Dudders ever touched Harry's things etc. after that...

Finwitch