[HPforGrownups] The cave potion and soul pieces (Re: OFH! Snape again )

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 141040

Jen
I guess my reluctance to think the soul piece is inside DD is 
feeling undecided about DD dying throughout HBP. I really don't see 
signs he's weakening before the potion. If anything he seems more 
energetic. Harry never sees flashes of anyone behind Dumbledore's 
eyes like DD saw in Harry's eyes when Voldemort was in there. So I'm 
still up in the air on this one.

Jen




Sherry:

The problem with the idea of the soul piece possessing the person who
destroys it is that Harry was not possessed by tom Riddle's diary.  Ginny
was possessed by the memory, but she didn't destroy the diary.  Harry
suffered no ill effects and certainly did not die from it.

sherry